The Lecture: A Cultural Construction of Privilege?

It’s been quite awhile since I’ve read an article that has inspired me to write a post on a Sunday afternoon. But today, I saw a link to an article in my Nuzzel feed titled “Is the lecture unfair?” and it piqued my interest. This recent article from the New York Times discusses findings from recent studies that show how lectures privilege students who come from privileged backgrounds. The author, Annie Murphy Paul, explains, 

…a growing body of evidence suggests that the lecture is not generic or neutral, but a specific cultural form that favors some people while discriminating against others, including women, minorities and low-income and first-generation college students. This is not a matter of instructor bias; it is the lecture format itself — when used on its own without other instructional supports — that offers unfair advantages to an already privileged population.” 

The idea that lectures create a biased learning environment that privileges certain students is not surprising to me — and it may not be surprising to you either. If you are familiar with my work, you’ve likely read other posts where I examine this notion. However, to see studies that excavate the lecture as a method of teaching that reinforces social inequities is worthy of discussion. The article reminded me of a video presentation I made back in 2011 titled “Expanding the Funnel,” which connected the flipped classroom model (a form of active learning) as a strategy for increasing degree attainment rates in community colleges (which saw an enrollment explosion in 2010-11, the time of the U.S. economic downturn). 

Community colleges have an open access policy, which means everyone one is welcome. They are the gateway to higher education in the United States and, as such, community college students are the most diverse group of learners in higher education. It is not uncommon for a single community college class to include students from multiple generations, ethnic minorities, first generation college students, ESL learners, students with cognitive differences (dyslexia, dysgraphia, etc.), and students with physical disabilities. This diversity creates a powerful, fertile soil for students to learn from each others’ experiences. However, not all instructors use active-learning strategies in their classes and, as such, the learning environments that students confront while in college are not as inclusive as the open-access mission of CCs.  Often, when I’ve discussed this topic with my peers, I’ve heard professors note that active learning does students who wish to transfer to a 4-year a “disservice,” because it doesn’t provide them with the skills needed to excel in the lecture environment.

Let’s keep this conversation going. It’s time to start examining the broader, social implications of pedagogy on degree attainment in higher education. All students are capable of learning and obtaining a college degree. Let’s support all of them.

Finally, we must not cast blame on faculty. We need to support faculty to understand how the way they teach a class impacts the percentage of students who experience deep learning.  Active learning is one step towards a more inclusive classroom.

Contemporary Issues Affecting College Students

This week in my Digital Citizenship class we are discussing social issues and why they should be considered to be of importance to college students. I personally had little interest in political issues until my senior year of high school when the 2008 Presidential candidates commanded attention in my Government class. Five issues that stand out to me in particular are racism, LGBT rights, the increasing cost of education, abortion, and rape culture.

  1. Racism – This issue has persisted for generations and shows little sign of being resolved any time soon. Here in the United States, personal prejudices against a race are merely the tip of the iceberg. Institutional racism (patterns of societal practices that favor one group over another on the basis of race) is a huge barrier for people of color that affects them as early as pre-school according to several studies, including this one reported by NPR. College students, especially those of color, should know about this because it is a sad reality that some students have unfair advantages over others and that the playing field is not even.
  2. LGBT rights – Similar to racism, discrimination and prejudice against these groups will not be eliminated in the near future by any means. College students encounter LGBT students on a daily basis. The college campus is a renowned place for exposing students to people of all walks of life. On a larger scale, the LGBT movement is a striking parallel to the Civil Rights Movement of the 1950s and ’60s. We are presented with groups of people that, in the simplest of terms, want to enjoy the rights granted to them by their country’s Constitution, rights that others take for granted.
  3. Increasing Cost of Education – Perhaps the most relatable issue on the list for college students, the price of an education has essentially tripled over the past 40 years. Students are having to take out more loans and are graduating with crushing debt. If these trends continue, the cost of an education will seem to outweigh the benefits. To some students, it already does. In the event that we have generations of students that are no longer considering higher education, there would be a huge detriment to our country on several levels.
  4. Abortion – The college environment has long been a place for young people to explore romantic and sexual possibilities, oftentimes with little regard to potential consequences. thus, abortion is an extremely important issue for students that will find themselves or someone that they care about, facing the reality of an unplanned pregnancy. The laws that are in place regarding abortion are challenged on a constant basis. Students should be aware of the status of proposed changes and how those changes will affect policy in the event that they find themselves in a situation where abortion is considered.
  5. Rape Culture – An issue that is garnering more and more attention, particularly in association with colleges and universities, is rape culture. As stated before, college students are inclined to engage in sexual relationships, but research has shown that many of them, male and female alike, cannot properly consent or obtain consent from their partners because they simply don’t understand the concept. Institutions are becoming more proactive about combating this lack of knowledge by providing education to their students and investigating claims under laws including, but not limited to, Title IX. I personally, now that I have been educated on EXACTLY what consent is and isn’t, correct others when I come across conversations on the topic, and hopefully others will as well.

 

 

 

 

Next Gen OpenROV

Our friends up at OpenROV have (almost) formally opened up their new Kickstarter project to fund their next generation ROV named Trident.  This was the unit vetted this summer up in Lake Tahoe (see the pic below) while we were dealing with our Oil Spill down here in SoCal.

New Open ROV test in Tahoe. image: OpenROV
New Open ROV test in Tahoe. image: OpenROV

By all accounts this unit is much more maneuverable and solves several of the mechanical issues we have dealt with in the current iteration/design.  OpenROV has opened up their Kickstarter page, but not formally launched.  The first few folks who sign up for one will be able to get one for half off…except we are about a year out from delivery.

No word on when their Kickstarter campaign will formally go to “on” but I suspect it will be coming up soon.

Check out our other posts (e.g. here or here or here) on our blog where we have very successfully used existing OpenROV models or their regular OpenROV page to find out more about this great open-source robotics company.

image: OpenROV
image: OpenROV

Social Issues?

For those that don’t know that when I am not buried three feet deep in textbooks and notes, shoving large amounts of information into my sometimes very tired brain,  I am a Bartender full-time and have been for many years. With the nature of the job, different topics come up from time to time that we discuss throughout any given shift.  Many of the Reg’s(Frequent customers) know that I am back in school and often ask questions pertaining current events, “how is it going? How do you like it? When is the graduation party”? Just the other day the question rang out again, “what is it like being so much older than most of the people there?” Most of the time the answer is with a shrug of the shoulders, “it is just fine I guess”.

For some reason or another that question has resonated in the front of my mind for the past few days, and I have given it some thought. Most of my fellow student have been very kind to me, and often enough I befriend lab partners, people from study groups or that I sit next to in class. The social experience that I have witnessed has been very pleasant and quite helpful. I know that with being a bit older the social pressures and issues that I receive will be much different than my fellow students.  I don’t suppose that I will have to worry about peer pressure, racism, being bullied (either cyber or in person), or the concerns with drugs and alcohol like my fellow student might. It may be for one reason or another, but I don’t give any of those issues much thought when it comes to affecting me or my direct surroundings. I can’t remember the last time I had to endure such problems.

I do feel the pressure of being accepted in the social aspect of social status and peer acceptance. I think all humans feel this when introduced to new environments either physical or psychological.  I will always remember that first day back to class. I walked into the classroom, and all of the students looked up at me, sat up in their chairs and started putting away their phones, grabbing for notebooks and sorts. I chuckled and found my seat in the front row and had a quick laugh. I remember hearing one of the girls say, “I thought he was our professor”. I knew then that I was going to like my return to school and to make the most of it.

There are many social issues that we all have to deal with either as a student or just as a human being. Sexuality, gender identification, social media, economics, and all that I have mentioned earlier. If we take the wisdom of, “always being true to ourselves and others; knowing that who you are is not only good enough but downright fantastic”, then many of these social issues have no leverage and not need to be a concern for you or anyone else. As far as the rest, remember that you are not alone and there is always someone to talk to about it.

As I always say, remember to smile, make someone laugh out loud, and have a fantastic day.

 

CDR

345G3 2015-09-13 05:48:22

After reading the articles assigned this week I have to admit I was very shocked with some of the facts mentioned in the articles. the one that specifically stood out to me was Children as consumers. I mean I was aware of how much time children and adults spend watching TV and other electronic devices but I never thought it was this bad. Spending more time watching television 15,000 to 18,000 hours of television than 12,000 hours spent per year in school is scary. What is ever scarier to me is the amount of children that watch thousands of advertisement commercials targeting them and some of the children aren’t able to comprehend the messages behind the advertisement and as a result believe the whole commercial. This is when the big problem begins, not only for children but also adults leading to obesity and body issues . The article also mentions how  children and teens influence parental purchases totaling over $130-670 billion a year. That explains why media’s main target is children. Several solutions in Europe regarding media regulation were brought up as a way to improve children’s overall health and stability by banning many of the advertisements, but my question is if this will even work or make things better? What is the U.S. doing in regards to this issue? What do you guys think?

 

Media as a Distraction

The part I found most interesting was this quote from page 11 of Chapter 1:

“The news media are central within American public thought, maybe not telling us what to think, but, to borrow from a popular phrase, focusing our attention on what to think about. Known as agenda-setting theory, this idea suggests that the repetition of issues in the news shapes what the public believes is most important. The abundance of news stories similar to the ones listed above directs us to think about entertainment as public enemy number one for kids in particular.”

This quote seemed very relevant to me. Media takes secondary issues and, essentially, manipulates the public into thinking that is what we should be focusing on. I feel like it’s like when a school shooting happens and the media blames video games and music. Immediately the public decides that those are the reasons this happened. After that, no one considers that anything else (like improper treatment of mental illness, gun control issues, etc) might have anything to do with it. Media did not necessarily cause the issues that they report on, but they distract from the issues that the public should be focusing on instead.

Another Discussion #1 Post

Hey guys! We really need to get on this! Maddie posted some really good thoughts on the book! What did you all think about the articles in eReserves?  (That was a lot of reading!).
I found the University of Michigan Health System 2015, “Television and Children” to be instense.  There was so many reasons why we shouldn’t be allowing our children to be watching so much tv, that I found the article to almost seem like satire!

Some examples the article stated were that TV affects children’s brain development, it produces violent behavor, it can traumatize children, or make them overweight!

Do you guys believe all those facts and studies to be accurate? If so, should our society be doing more to stop the excessive amount of time in front of the tv?

Online Blog

I found these articles to be a pretty interesting read. Some areas I could already  guess to be true while other areas of the article surprised me entirely. The first article by Jolls and Wilson talked about media literacy on a broad scheme of things from the past to present. England and Canada were really the first two countries to experiment with the word “media literacy”. The U.S came along later and began researching media literacy based on the knowledge of other countries and used them to see the effects with the radio. A quote in this article that really stood out to me was by Marshall McLuhan which said “how one receives a message is just as important as the message itself”. This quote I think is really important because it shows that we can become knowledgeable by looking at the who, what, why, how, etc. of a piece of media. I agree with the article when it states that questions really are key when it comes to understanding media. However it is also rare for people to question things as it is much easier to just accept something for what it looks like. The article also explained how the same piece of media can have dozens of different interpretations based on the views, beliefs, and self-evaluation of the person looking at it. The last two article dealing with “Children as Consumers” and the “Health System by the University of Michigan” was a spot on yet troubling read. For the media to mainly spend all their time money and effort to advertise and manipulate children seems criminal. Also with how much TV watching goes on in basically every single household kids and pre-teens are suffering health wise and socially. The younger generation aren’t as active and see ads for fatty foods and so on. However on the flip side TV can be an entertaining and positive thing. It comes down to having everything in a balance not having too much or too little.

Genres of The Brewhouse

As a person goes through their lives the amount and importance of different genres that they communicate in can be lost on the average person. The understanding of different genres affects the way a person communicates and their understanding of communication in different scenarios. A person will communicate differently with different people depending on the genre of communication that is expected with the given situation. The reason for this is the genre that is chosen is meant to express the point in the most clear possible form given the particular situation. If a person is writing a love letter they would use a style of writing that the reader would expect to see in a love letter. It would be endearing, persuasive, and emotional. If a person was writing a legal brief they would not choose the same genre that they would for a love letter, it would convey the wrong message. Kerry Dirk states in “Navigating Genres” that “Picking up a text, readers not only classify it and expect a certain form, but also make assumptions about the text’s purposes, its subject matter, its writer, and its expected reader”(Dirk,2010).
In a persons everyday life they will use several different genres to communicate most effectively. During work at The Brewhouse my understanding of the genre of communication used in the workplace is essential to my success as an employee. In order to understand something like our schedule a person would need to understand the genre in which the schedule is written.IMG_1343 Telling the date and time an employee works might be clear to everyone looking at the schedule, however where their shift is, is only clear to employees who understand how the sections are communicated between each other. The genre of communication would be understanding where the backroom, booths, or front room are.
One of the main purposes of developing a specific genre for intercommunication between employees is to speed up the communication process. The Brewhouse has specific terminology that would only be understood by employees in that specific restaurant.IMG_1347
86 is a common term in restaurants for something that the restaurant is currently out of stock. Even more specific to The Brewhouse would be 86 Poppers, referring to the restaurant being out of jalapeno poppers. This type of short hand communication speeds up intercommunication and makes the restaurant more efficient.
Another way The Brewhouse speeds up intercommunication between its’ staff is the use of computer printouts from the waiters to the kitchen staff. This genre allows the wait staff to quickly punch in orders on touch screen computers located throughout the restaurant, and the order is delivered immediately to the kitchen staff.IMG_1346
These tickets tell the kitchen what to make, but they also inform other servers where the food should be delivered. This allows the restaurant to run significantly more efficient and without an understanding of the genre of communication used by the staff a person would not be able to work effectively.
Different genres are used throughout a person’s daily life. An understanding of which genre to use in a particular situation is what makes someone an effective communicator. According to Dirk, “If they encounter a situation new to them, it is the genres they have acquired in the past that they can use to shape their new action. Every genre they acquire, then, expands their genre repertoire and simultaneously shapes how they might view new situations”(Dirk,2010). The understanding of new genres allows a person to expand their ability to communicate properly in different situations.

Lowe, C. (2010). Writing spaces: Readings on writing. West Lafayette, Ind.: Parlor Press.

What we see through T.V.

I found the article University of Michigan Health System very informational. Though the section about “Can TV influence children’s attitudes toward themselves and others?” I found to be completely true, as I grew up I’ve come to notice that as a child I took what was on tv seriously and thought it was true to reality.  Like it says in the article “Children learn to accept the stereotypes represented on television.” Even though I come from a mix of races, I honestly thought for the longest time that all black people acted like they were from the “hood” after watching Friday. As silly as it sounds I tried to avoid people associating me with black people because I didn’t want people to see me as the women in the movie.

The statement “Thin women are disproportionately represented on TV. The heavier a female
character, the more negative comments were made about her,” Kills me so much because as I began to gain wait I felt like I would be projected like an ugly person mainly because I didn’t see curvy people on tv and when I did it was either in a comical or a cruel way. For example the youtube star who criticized “fat” people  for being over weight which could cause children this day and age to think that being overweight could be negative and cause them to have all sorts of physiological problems, it’s hard  for girls at a young age to be happy with themselves, now their being criticized for their weight or even their looks.

I’m wondering what you all think of the perception tv gives us and how It makes you feel?