Posts

KVTA Oil Spill Interview

Oil Seeps 101

Tar ball strand line at the wrack line at Ventura State Beach on May 30, 2015.

Tar ball strand line at the wrack line at Ventura State Beach on May 30, 2015.

We have been getting lots of inquires about this crazy tarballing going on across Santa Barbara, Ventura, and Los Angeles Counties.  I thought I would give a quick overview of tar balls in our part of the world; the Southern California Bight.

Just-deposited fresh tar ball at Zuma Beach, Los Angeles County.  May 30, 2015.

Just-deposited fresh tar ball at Zuma Beach, Los Angeles County. May 30, 2015.

Oil Seeps In Our History

Natural sandy beach oil seep in Santa Barbara.  Image: USGS.

Natural sandy beach oil seep in Santa Barbara. Image: USGS.

Oil has been deep underground for millions of years, more or less undisturbed.  Indeed our sucking out all that stored carbon and then effectively spitting that carbon up into our atmosphere is the central driver of climate change and (what I like to call) global weirding (aka global warming).  Petroleum is mostly the product of dead plankton and plants, not so much dead dinosaurs as the popular conception normally goes (but I digress…).  Oil and gas essentially build up in porous subsurface rock formations capped by impervious rock.  This creates an oil and/or gas pocket which humans learned to tap beginning in the mid-to-late 1800s.  But long before we ever learned to stick fancy metal straws down into these hydrocarbon rock pools, that “black gold” has been naturally leaking up to the surface since these formations first formed.  These leaks or seeps happen when the overlying rock formations develop fractures or cracks in them, letting the oil or gas flow up to the surface quickly or slowly.  Seeps have played important roles in human society for thousands of years.

Chumash tomol.  Image: from www.missionscalifornia.com

Chumash tomol. Image: www.missionscalifornia.com

Our local seeps in Santa Barbara and Ventura Counties featured most prominently in Chumash culture and technology.  We have evidence of humans using seep tar at least as early as 5,000 B.C.E. with Chumash actively trading their tar with other, distant tribes for at least the past 1,000 years.  Perhaps the most iconic use of the tar seeping from the ground across our region were the Chumash ocean-going tomols.  These Chumash canoes were unusual and not constructed as a watertight vessel per se.  Instead, these vessels were constructed of planks.  Once assembled the final waterproofing included scooping up a bunch of tar from a local seep and then plastering/in-filling of any gaps between planks to create a superior seal and watertight boat.  Spanish explorer Juan Rodriguez Cabrillo was particularly impressed with this technology and noted these unique canoes in the logs of his 1542 exploration of the Ventura and Santa Barbara coasts.  Cabrillo even used Chumash tar to caulk and repair his own vessels.  Our current Chumash people are active in preserving their traditions and culture and continue to construct traditional tomols to traverse the 17+ mile gap from the mainland to our channel islands.

Chumash arrive at Santa Cruz Island in a modern Tomol.  Photo: National Park Service.

Chumash arrive at Santa Cruz Island in a modern Tomol. Photo: National Park Service.

 

Summerland oil piers near Santa Barbara, circa 1901-1903. Image: Title Insurance and Trust / C.C. Pierce Photography Collection, USC Libraries.

Summerland oil piers near Santa Barbara, circa 1901-1903. Image: Title Insurance and Trust / C.C. Pierce Photography Collection, USC Libraries.

Our first definitive confirmation of natural seeps depositing tar balls on our local beaches dates to 1772 and the journal of Padre Pedro Font (a member of Juan Bautista De Anza’s colonizing expedition).  Font noted tar balls on the beach and slow motion seeps pouring asphaltum (which is just what it sounds like) down cliffs and bluffs into the ocean.  With the European settlement of California, more modern extraction and uses of oil began to take hold.  Oil extraction was initially concentrated at and near surface seeps where the emerging tar was scooped up directly, soon to be quarried as we traditionally mine gravel or other rocks.  In those early days of the mid 1800’s, harvested tar was used principally to pave roads, fuel oil lamps, and as a lubricant for heavy machinery.  From 1870-1890 more and more oil and gas wells sprang up as settlers encountered petroleum where they had hoped to find water in their boreholes.  All heck broke loose following the first-in-the-world offshore oil production derricks (via long, wooden piers jutting out into the surf) off of Summerland in 1896.  And the rest, as we say, is history.

Summerland offshore wells near the end of the play of this nearshore reservoir.  Image: Museum of Ventura County.

Summerland offshore wells near the end of the play of this nearshore reservoir. Image: Museum of Ventura County.

An Ongoing Flow

Oil and gas seeps presents themselves both on the terrestrial surface and the ocean bottom.  Flow can be highly variable, changing with seasons, tectonic pressures, temperatures, and a myriad of factors we poorly understand.  This can complicate the source tracking when we are interested in figuring out if a tarring event or individual slick originated from a seep or a spill.

Remotely Operated Vehicle video still showsing a crab near the top of extruding tar on a tar mound in the Santa Barbara Channel. Lack of colonizing sessile organisms suggests that this mound is quite young.  Image source: Lorenson, et al. 2009.

Remotely Operated Vehicle video still showsing a crab near the top of extruding tar on a tar mound in the Santa Barbara Channel. Lack of colonizing sessile organisms suggests that this mound is quite young. Image source: Lorenson, et al. 2009.

A tarwhip extruding from an extensive tar mound offshore Pt. Conception at a water depth of 41 m. The length seen in the photo is estimated to be about 3 m. Several tar whips were observed, all extruding from tar mounds, some of which were clearly broken off, and some that did not retain buoyancy and fell to the ocean floor.

An approximately 3 m-long tarwhip extruding from an extensive tar mound offshore of Pt. Conception at a depth of 41 m. During this dive, many such tar whips were observed, all extruding from tar mounds. Some such whips broke off and floated to the surface while others did not retain buoyancy and fell to the ocean floor. Image source: Lorenson, et al. 2009.

Released oil and gas experiences a wide array of possible fates, including migration to the atmosphere, hanging out in the water column or surface layer, deposition upon the benthos, and degradation/transformation by the microbial community.

The fate of oil from a natural seep in the Santa Barbara Channel.  Image source: Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (2009).

The fate of oil from a natural seep in the Santa Barbara Channel. Image source: Woods Hole Oceanographic Institution (2009).

Natural Oil Seeps in the Santa Barbara Channel

We have a wide range of naturally oil seeps across Ventura and Santa Barbara Counties.  Examples of known seeps and some of the resulting slicks are below.  You can also check out this killer site from the USGS documenting known seeps across California.

Southern California Bight showing possible oil slicks and seeps.  Colors coded by confidence level where green>red>pink.  Possible oil pollution slicks are seen in yellow tones.  Image source: Fugro NPA Limited satellite mapping services.

Southern California Bight showing possible oil slicks and seeps. Colors coded by confidence level where green>red>pink. Possible oil pollution slicks are seen in yellow tones. Image source: Fugro NPA Limited satellite mapping services.

 

An Ongoing Flow

One of the particular challenges with tracking surface slicks from seeps or spills revolves around the complicated surface currents and eddies we experience in the Santa Barbara Channel.  This is due to both the geography of the Santa Barbara Channel, Point Conception, and the Transverse Range.  As a result, we can get movement in virtually any direction, although we generally get migration eastward and southward during the spring and summer.   To date, the surface slick from the Refugio Oil Spill has primarily migrated offshore with two main lobes, one going more or less straight offshore and a second migrating eastward down the coast.  As of this writing, we have no direct evidence that oil from the Refugio Spill migrated any great distance.  However the tar balling of beaches in Santa Monica Bay and the Ventura coastlines might have been translocated oil from that Refugio source.  Below is an overview of the general surface flow patterns in the Santa Barbara Channel.

Dominant patterns of surface currents in the Santa Barbara Channel.

Dominant patterns of surface currents in the Santa Barbara Channel.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Seep or Spill?

Example tar ball chromatograms from the Santa Barbara Channel.  Image after 2009.

Example tar ball chromatograms from the Santa Barbara Channel. Chromatograms of selected tarball samples. Total ion chromatogram (TIC) of aliphatic (A) and aromatic (B) fractions; Selected ion monitoring (SIM) chromatograms of m/z 191, Hopanes (C), and m/z 217, Steranes (D,E,F). Compounds identified in Table 2-1. Legend : MAS, monoaromatic steranes; Steranes, C26 to C29 regular steranes; Hopanes, C27 to C35 regular hopanes; BN, 28,30-bisonorhopane; UCM, Unresolved Complex Mixture. 23T, C23-tricyclic terpane; C24, C25, C27, C38, tricyclic terpanes; T, triplet, defined in text; Ts and Tm, defined in text; BN, bisnorhopane; ab29, ab30, ab31 through 35 (S & R epimers), ab-hopanes with carbon numbers; O, Oleanane; and G, Gammacerane. (D, E, F) Mass chromatograms (m/z 217) of C27, C28, and C29 steranes and C27 diasteranes in a selected coastal tar residues representing Families 22, 212, and 32. Legend: S,R = epimers of aaa27, 28, 29 and bb27, 28, 29 steranes. Image after Lorenson, et al. 2009.

The only definitive way to tell if the oil presenting itself on a given beach is from a seep or from an anthropogenic release (i.e. the Refugio Spill) is via chemical forensics.  We do this by “fingerprinting” the oil.  This essentially means grabbing the oil, getting it nice and liquid-y and then running those sample through a machine that can characterize the various chemical compounds.  This analyzer can distinguish biomarkers or the “fingerprint” of amazingly complex organic compounds and the isotopes of individual carbon atoms that comprise a given oil sample.  Frequent targets that will help with distinguishing the source formation include unusually “heavy” d13C, high C35 ab-hopane 22S and 22R epimers compared to C34, and prominent sulfur-containing PAHs, such as dibenzothiophenes.  The last step is to run a sample of the candidate source oil (say from the Refugio Pipeline crude) and see if the two compounds’ peaks overlap.

Although the chemical components are common to essentially all tar balls, their relative proportions will vary with the oil sources.  The chemical “fingerprinting” should use both the ratios of these array of constituents, plus additional markers from both aliphatic and aromatic hydrocarbons (see Hostettler et al., 2004).

The chemical composition of the tarballs also sheds light on their geochemical history. Despite tons of offshore, shallow seeps, and the constant impingement of tar onto the shoreline, little is known about the mechanics of the hydrocarbon formation in the shallow seeps, specific sources of tarballs, or their transport from the marine environment onto the shore.

While not perfect, this “fingerprinting” has been used to track not only the source of oil, but look at how that material has moved across our nearshore seascape.  As we know that tar balls from offshore seeps can be transported significant distances from their sources by ocean currents, oceanographers have used tar ball source tracking to infer circulation patterns and nearshore currents.  This amounts to researchers using oil as effectively a drifter.

Grunion & Sand Crabs in harms way

There are many critters particularly at risk with this oil spill.  While our historic worry/focus has been on our rocky intertidal communities and on warm fuzzies (such as these cute marine mammals and endangered sand-nesting birds), other critters are at risk too.  In particular the animals dwelling in the swash zone of our sandy beaches.  What I am most worried about here are the sand crabs (Emerita analoga) that are the food for a huge number of beach-dwelling birds and animals and our California grunion (Leuresthes tenuis).

Large sand crab carapace in the fresh tar line at Oxnard Shores, Ventura County on May 30, 2015.

Large sand crab carapace in the fresh tar line at Oxnard Shores, Ventura County on May 30, 2015.

Sand crabs make their living migrating up and down the beach with the tides (they live in the sand, sticking up their food-collectors to harvest their planktonic food and the waves wash over their sand-home), keeping themselves right at the swash zone where the waves hit.  That’s right where all these tarballs are washing up.  As of yesterday, we have been finding dead sand crabs in amongst the freshest wave of tarballs arriving on our beaches in Ventura County.

It is too early to say if we are seeing a significant mortality event within our sand crab population, but it is concerning that we are seeing so many dead guys (not mere cast-off exoskeletons or dead juveniles).

 

Given the fact that sand crab numbers have been low this year prior to the onset of the pipeline break/oil spill, any tar-induced mortality might prove harmful to the population and sandy beach community overall.  The bright side of this is that these are resilient and highly variable populations and we may see no effect.

A grunion run near Cabrillo Aquarium in Los Angeles, CA.  Image: CBS News

A grunion run near Cabrillo Aquarium in Los Angeles, CA. Image: CBS News

 

When it comes to California grunion, the worry is that we are in peak spawning time.  These amazing fish swim up to the beach at night to lay their eggs before rolling and flopping back into the water.  Their eggs chill out in the sand until they are ready to hatch with the next series of high tides.

 

Both sand crabs and grunion are vulnerable to both the toxic oil and the clean-up process alike.  Simply skimming the oil off the very uppermost surface of the sand is not an issue, but digging into the sand translates into possibly digging into these guys and killing them.  Clean-up crews need to be as careful as is reasonable.

See this e-mail from our queen grunion champion Dr. Karen Martin:

Whatever their source may be, these tar balls have the potential to impact beach and nearshore animals and plants, including the California Grunion…

[the impacted areas] are known spawning locations for the California Grunion, an endemic, iconic marine species. Any eggs still on shore this weekend are ready to hatch and likely to emerge during the high tides at night over the past and next few days. However, the tar balls in the intertidal zone are very nearly in the location of the band of buried grunion eggs.

With all appropriate  human safety precautions, when cleaning the beaches, it is important to leave the sand as undisturbed as possible if the contamination is only at the surface. The best practice seems to be gentle manual removal of the surface petroleum, with flat shovels or hand rakes. Some people are using cat-litter scoops.

We are still in the midst of the peak spawning season for the California Grunion. The full moon Tuesday June 2 will be followed by nights with potential runs on Tuesday, Wednesday, Thursday, and Friday. Grunion usually spawn multiple times over their lifespans. It is rare that they die during spawning runs. If you do see an unusual mortality event, please let me know as soon as possible…

…Please recall that after this week the nests of eggs will be present on shore for the following two weeks. Keeping vehicles and other forms of disturbance above the high tide line of Tuesday’s highest tide is the best way to protect them.

Thanks for your care of our beaches and natural resources during this difficult time.

 

Tarring of Ventura

We are seeing tar ball strand lines as the high tide retreats this morning.   Intermixed in these tar lines are dead sand crabs/carapaces.

Tar balls not evident near Hueneme Pier but many consistent, wispy tar lines starting at Oxnard Shores / west of Channel Islands Harbor.

More details as we observe during today’s monitoring.

   

   

More Beaches Closed!

Oil clean-up crews at Haskells Beach mid-morning May 29. 2015

Oil clean-up crews at Haskells Beach mid-morning May 29. 2015

Holy cow!  It has been a crazy day.  One of our teams sampling Haskell’s Beach (near the Bacara Resort) north Coal Oil Point was basically given the boot.  Various clean-up teams are now sweeping the beaches from El Capitan to Goleta and the Incident Command has now shut down public access to all of those beaches. This is a huge expansion of the closure area and seems to confirm our concerns beginning mid last week that much of the oil arriving to beaches down to Coal Oil Point was indeed pipeline crude and not merely regular, background tar seep deposition.

While one of our teams checking Carpinteria found nothing particularly abnormal about the tar balls there at 4pm today, we now have reports of dime-to-baseball sized tar balls washing up on several of our monitoring beaches here in our own backyards in Ventura County.  It is unclear if this is related to the spill, but we RARELY IF EVER get this kind of tarring on these beaches.  This is certainly an unusual event and seems very suspicious.  We need to have the fingerprinting of the oil to confirm but at a minimum, this is very weird.

Here is a quick video by Paul Spaur summarizing the goings on before the beach was closed:

 

We will post more when we know more.

Newly boomed off sandy beach edge at Haskell's Beach May 29, 2015

More boom, less people. Newly boomed off sandy beach edge at Haskell’s Beach May 29, 2015

From the LA Times about 15 minutes ago:

The cleanup response to the oil spill that fouled miles of beaches along the Santa Barbara County coast will now extend to Ventura County, where tar balls have been spotted on beaches, officials said Friday.

The pipeline’s owners said it will dispatch cleanup contractors to Hollywood, McGrath and San Buenaventura beaches in Ventura County, though federal authorities have not confirmed whether the oil there is from the spill.

“Until we know more, we will act as if it is related to our incident,” said Rick McMichael, senior director of operations at Plains All American Pipeline, which operates the pipeline.

read the full story on the LA Times website.

Workers continue to clean the shoreline at Refugio State Beach in Santa Barbara County after a crude oil pipeline ruptured on May 19, spilling thousands of gallons into the ocean. Photo: Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Times

Workers continue to clean the shoreline at Refugio State Beach in Santa Barbara County after a crude oil pipeline ruptured on May 19, spilling thousands of gallons into the ocean. Photo: Genaro Molina / Los Angeles Times

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

From the Ventura County Star Website:

By Friday afternoon, crews were cleaning up tar balls at San Buenaventura and McGrath.

Two beaches north of Santa Barbara, also in the Channel Coast district, were closed last week after an estimated 21,000 gallons of oil spilled into the ocean off Refugio State Beach. There’s no indication the tar balls on the Ventura beaches were related to that spill nearly 50 miles away. But officials don’t know where they came from at this point.

“An initial analysis came back inconclusive as to what the source is,” said Kevin McGowan, manager of the Ventura County Sheriff’s Office of Emergency Services. The Emergency Operations Center has been activated to support the investigation and cleanup efforts.

McGowan was with a team early Friday checking out the sites where the oil was reported.

“They range from the size of a dime or a quarter to a dinner plate,” he said. “Stretches (of the tar balls) span anywhere from 10 to 50 feet long.”

No closures were reported Friday afternoon.

“There doesn’t appear to be a significant threat to public health or wildlife in Ventura County at this point,” said Chris Stephens, the county’s resource management director. “Our goal at this point is to find the oil, remove it and mitigate any environmental impact it may have caused.”

Those responding to Ventura-area beaches Friday would assess whether the tar balls need to be cleaned up. County officials said cleanup teams had been deployed to the area.

A fly-over of the ocean done as part of the cleanup efforts of the Santa Barbara County oil spill was expected to include the Ventura County area Friday. McGowan said he had not yet heard the results from Unified Command, but so far, there were no reports of oil in the water off the Ventura coast.

Earlier this week, a 7-mile stretch of coastline along Santa Monica Bay was closed after globs of oily goo washed ashore. Officials said the area might reopen Friday after a two-day cleanup effort.

 

Update: 6:30pm

My students are reporting lots and lots of small to medium-sized tar balls washing up on western Ventura County Beaches.  These tar balls are dense enough to begin forming a line of tar at the strand / high tide line.  We are also seeing dead sand crabs (one of the foci of our sandy beach work and a keystone species for sandy beach ecology) intermixed at this tar sand line at McGrath State Beach and Emma Wood State Beach.

McGrath tar ball stand line on May 29, 2015.

McGrath tar ball stand line on May 29, 2015.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Dead sand crabs (Emerita analoga) at McGrath State Beach tar ball stand line which formed on May 29, 2015.

Dead sand crabs (Emerita analoga) at McGrath State Beach tar ball stand line which formed on May 29, 2015.

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

McGrath tar ball stand line on May 29, 2015.

McGrath tar ball stand line on May 29, 2015.

McGrath tar ball stand line 05-29-15b

>10cm wide tar ball at McGrath State Beach tar ball stand line on May 29, 2015.

EmmaWood tar ball stand line 05-29-15c

Tar ball strand line at McGrath State Beach in Ventura, CA on May 29, 2015.

PIRatE Lab Tour

Here is a quick tour of our PIRatE Lab’s lab.  We have been getting several requests about our lab and decided to give you a sense of our set-up.

 

Sand samples from across the Southern California Bight.

Sand samples from across the Southern California Bight.

Open ROV 2.7: The Black Pearl on our custom launching platform.

Open ROV 2.7: The Black Pearl on our custom launching platform.

Our Phantom ROV being overhauled and rebuilt.

Our Phantom ROV being overhauled and rebuilt.

 

We’ve also had lots of questions about oil; what it looks like, what it smells like, and how sticky it is.  We have posted our observations about oil before, but here is what the samples look like back in the lab:

Week 1: The oiling so far

Monitoring the Oil

Beach Oiling plus our monitoring beaches.

Intensity of beach oiling plus our monitoring beaches.

As the clean-up progresses, so does our monitoring.  We now have sampled an array of sites that span the region of potential impact (Gaviota to downtown Santa Barbara) and the range of observed intensity of oiling.  We are now beginning to shift gears a bit to have some of our crew focus on our other assessment efforts (beach visitation rates, our robotic data collection assessment tools, etc.).

Documented Impacts (as of May 27, 2015)

Light oiling at Bacara Beach on May 26, 2105.

Light oiling at Bacara Beach on May 26, 2105.

Confirming our initial observations from the very beginning of this spill, much of the oiling and obvious impact has been concentrated in and around Refugio State Beach.  Today Unified Command reported  7.4 km (4.6 mi) of beach have been heavily oiled (red in the above map) and 14.3 km (8.9 mi) of beach lightly oiled (orange, yellow, and green in the above map).

Our table below lists the data available from Unified Command as of the Wednesday.  We have observed a small amount of dead fish, an unusual concentration of dead sand crabs (Emerita analog) and several oiled brown pelicans (Pelecanus occidentalis, which may or may not be included in the reported totals below) over the past week.  Most of the marine mammals recovered to date have been California sea lions (Zalophus californianus) and northern elephant seals (Mirounga angustirostris), generally in poor condition independent of the spill/oiling.  Most of the oiled birds have been brown pelicans.

 

Northern elephant seal juvenile El Capitan State Beach 05-20-15b

Northern elephant seal juvenile at El Capitan State Beach on the morning of May 20, 2015 prior to the first oil arriving to this beach.

Bacara Beach fishing closure sign due to Refugio Oil Spill.

Bacara Beach fishing closure sign due to Refugio Oil Spill.

A fishing closure is in effect until further notice.  The aerial exclusion zone (below a 1000′ ceiling) now in effect is slated to terminate Friday, May 29.

Oiled Beach
Heavily Oiled 7.4 km
Lightly Oiled 14.3 km
Birds
oiled 33
dead 16
Marine Mammals
oiled 18
dead 9
Oil Recovered
oily water mix 38080 l
oily vegetation 310 yd 3
oily sand 760 yd 3
oiled protective equip 141 yd 3
oiled soil 2610 yd 3
boom deployed 0.68 km
hard bottom 0.56 km
absorbent (floating) 1.24 km
Assets
personnel 956
vessels 16
shoreline teams 5
hellicopters 2

 

 

Sampling Coal Oil Point on May 22, 2015.

Sampling Coal Oil Point on May 22, 2015 (click to see a quick video of our sampling area.)

Yet another test

asasdda

asdasdad

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

 

Oil exclusion boom at Gaviota State Beach on May 24, 2015.

Oil exclusion boom at Gaviota State Beach on May 24, 2015.

Oil exclusion boom at Gaviota State Beach on May 24, 2015.

Only lightly oiled Campus Point Beach on May 22, 2015.

Only lightly oiled Campus Point Beach on May 22, 2015.

Feds order pipeline company to clean up SB coastline & Investors React

Federal authorities on Wednesday issued a cleanup order to the company whose underground pipeline last week spilled thousands of gallons of crude oil into the Pacific Ocean and marred several miles of Santa Barbara County coastline.

“Our action today is to make sure the oil response work continues until the Santa Barbara County coastline is restored,” Jared Blumenfeld, administrator for the U.S. EPA’s Pacific Southwest region, said in a news release.

The order from the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency and the U.S. Coast Guard requires Plains All American Pipeline, which owns and operates the pipeline, to continue its cleanup work on land, on the beach and in the ocean. It further orders the company to clean up all remaining contamination and to contain the oil to ensure no more crude is released into the environment.

The order also establishes time lines and cleanup requirements under the federal Clean Water Act. Federal officials say the move will ensure a prompt and thorough restoration of ocean waters and shoreline fouled by the May 19 spill near Refugio State Beach.

By June 6, the company must submit a work plan and detail how it will sample the air, water, rocks and soil, the order says.

The action comes as an ongoing cleanup operation has swelled to nearly 1,000 people, including federal and state employees, environmental contractors hired by Plains and trained volunteers.

Plains on Wednesday also continued a slow-moving excavation of the soil around the section of pipe that broke, action required under a separate order issued Friday by the Pipeline and Hazardous Materials Safety Administration. That order forces the company to remove the portion of pipeline for testing to determine what caused the spill and the condition of the pipe when it failed.

The latest order comes two days after Plains said it will also investigate the integrity of pipeline at four other locations along Line 901. The pipe transports crude oil 11 miles from Floras to Gaviota and then to refineries throughout Southern California.

The spill released as much as 101,000 gallons of crude from the pipeline, according to the company. An estimated 21,000 gallons of oil flowed downhill from the spill site through a culvert and into the Pacific.

Source: Feds order pipeline company to clean up Santa Barbara coastline – LA Times

 

 

Investors are starting to take note as well and the industry is starting a strong pushback against the LA Times story.  See this story from the Houston Business Journal:

Plains All American Pipeline LP’s safety record factors into investor reaction to oil spill

Plains All American Pipeline LP has had to defend its safety record to a public concerned with the environmental impacts of its oil spill resulting from a pipeline rupture off the coast of California, but investors are watching too.

The price per share of Plains All American LP (NYSE: PAA) stock has slipped ever since the fiasco began, but up until now, much of that trading can be attributed to retail investors who tend to be more reactionary and a bit less sophisticated, said Sunil Sibal, director and master limited partnership analyst at New Orleans-based Global Hunter Securities LLC.

Safety records matter in that they can indicate more intrinsic problems than any isolated incident, but Sibal is fairly confident of Plains’ capabilities.

There was much media fanfare over the fact that Plains’ ranked fifth in the number of incidents or infractions reported to thePipeline and Hazardous Material Safety Administration, which has a database of roughly 1,700 pipeline operators, the LA Times reported.

Plains spokesman Patrick Hodgins has since come out and defended its record to media by reiterating that Plains is one of the largest midstream operators in the nation, and operates substantially more pipeline than many other companies in the PHMSA database.

 

Students in the News

Senior ESRM member Tevin Schmitt being interviewed by KEYT3's Alys Martinez at Gaviota State Beach on March 24, 2015.

Senior ESRM major Tevin Schmitt being interviewed by KEYT3’s Alys Martinez at Gaviota State Beach on March 24, 2015.

Great to see more stories focusing on our students and their dedicated efforts as the getting out into the regular coverage of spill impacts.  The two most recent of these featured some of our field sampling over the weekend.  Many of the students in our field crews have been canceling things right and left.  This spill happened during a brief window between the end of the semester and the start of our regular summer field season when most of them plan a brief period of relaxation.  The two recent stories that best highlight our student-centric approach were Alys Martinez’s piece for Santa Barbara’s KEYT3 news and Megan Diskin’s piece for the Ventura County Star.  They are below and on our Press page.

From the KEYT3 piece:

“It’s really important to do long-term monitoring programs like this to get baseline data, so you can know exactly what the communities are, before a disaster like an oil spill hits. Then, we can study after an oil spill and see what the effects truly are,”  student Tevin Schmitt said.

see the video here: University students study beach impacts from oil spill

From the Ventura County Star piece:

Steele has been part of a three-year study of health of the ocean, studying Southern California beaches stretching from Santa Barbara to Orange counties, she said. Through a university program called Project ACCESO, Hispanic and low-income undergraduate students from the university and other area schools such as Moorpark College and Ventura College can gain research experiences in science, technology, engineering and mathematics, Steele said.

read the piece here: Researchers race clock to collect samples near spill

Tevin Schmitt speaking to KEYT3 news at Gaviota Beach on May 23, 2015.

Tevin Schmitt speaking to KEYT3 news at Gaviota Beach on May 23, 2015.

 

note: this VC Star piece is behind a paid fire wall.  You must pay to see the full piece with text and images, but given the number of requests I’ve been getting, I have posted the text of the story below:

Researchers race clock to collect samples near spill

Researchers from CSU Channel Islands were trying to get ahead of spilled oil lingering in the ocean off the coast off Santa Barbara County to collect samples from area beaches before the crude hits the shore.

Dr. Clare Steele, a lecturer in environmental science and resource management at the Camarillo university, said she planned to lead a team of five to Gaviota State Beach on Sunday to get an idea of the waterfront’s biological diversity “so we can get a baseline of research” to measure the effects of the spill.

Steele has been part of a three-year study of health of the ocean, studying Southern California beaches stretching from Santa Barbara to Orange counties, she said. Through a university program called Project ACCESO, Hispanic and low-income undergraduate students from the university and other area schools such as Moorpark College and Ventura College can gain research experiences in science, technology, engineering and mathematics, Steele said.

The timetable for some of their research was accelerated after as much as 105,000 gallons of oil escaped from a pipeline in Santa Barbara County on Tuesday and about 21,000 gallons of the crude made its way into the ocean off Refugio State Beach near Goleta.

Some students were expected to join the study in June as part of the Summer Scholars Institute, but they’ve volunteered to start early.

Steele said she hopes oil hasn’t gotten to Gaviota State Beach yet because it’s unlikely officials will let the team survey the area if it has been affected. On Sunday, a mixture of recent graduates of CSU Channel Islands and a Moorpark College student will be headed north to gather samples.

Sean Anderson, an associate professor in environmental science and resource management at Channel Islands, had led a team to collect samples Wednesday to El Capitan beach near the spill. Steele said a team also collected samples Friday at Coal Oil Point.

The excursions don’t just involve bottling samples of sand, Steele said. The team will look to see what kind of invertebrates, birds and marine mammals are living at the beach and whether there are dogs, people or surfers there. One key observation is to note whether kelp has washed ashore because it can be an important food source for birds, Steele said.

“We’ll also count how many sand crabs there are per square meter,” Steele said.

Researchers will take a “more intensive look” at creatures living in the sand because they may be a significant indicator of the effects of the nearby spill, Steele said.

“The sand crabs are right there in the swash zone where the oil meets the sand,” Steele said.

She said it is hard to predict the recovery time of some of the beaches affected by the spill because not all beaches naturally have the same level of biological diversity and it may change from one year to the next.

 

 

 

 

 

Holiday or no…

Our teams are mustering for another field day of monitoring the ecological and social impacts of this spill.

Much of the genesis of our current Sandy Beach work is grounded in our efforts to bring folks into field science who would not otherwise be engaged in a so-called STEM (Science, Technology, Engineering, and Math) discipline.  For more than a decade CSU Channel Islands has been developing deep engagement opportunities for students who are first-generation college goers and from underrepresented in typical college populations.  These folks have traditionally had a difficult time entering technical fields and are a central focus of our University from day one.

Our ESRM program does that engagement and highly technical training with Remotely Piloted Systems (UAVs aka drones & ROVs), with monitoring work on Santa Rosa Island, field sampling in estuaries, on beaches, over reefs, and in coastal mountains.  We do it in our GIS labs, greenhouses, and oh-so cluttered ecological restoration, robotics, geomorphology, and water quality labs spaces.  We also do it out of the typical classroom (every one of our upper division courses is field based or has a substantial field component).  We do it at our new Field Station on Santa Rosa Island, on our main campus, and in field classes across California Louisiana, Coasta Rica, and the Cook Islands.

Our Summer Institute (that formally begins in one week, albeit we pulled the trigger early as this spill happened) is a specific program wherein our faculty and students here at CSU Channel Islands collaborate with faculty and undergraduates at our local community colleges (Oxnard CC, Ventura CC, and Santa Barbara CC).  All the students are hired and paid for their fulltime work as researchers.

How cool is it that young people who may have recently not been sure of their career path are out sampling the human and natural worlds to quantify the impact of this (hu)man-made disaster?!?  

This is the way you engage folks and this is how you birth the next generation of field scientists and natural resource managers.

Alright, enough talk, it is time to get out there and GET MORE DATA…